Timeline

2,441 featured entries in All time

Page 27 of 49 · showing 1301–1350 of 2441

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
I appreciate your challenges and it gives me a chance to explain how things work instead of one offs and generalizations. 1. Just like Codesmith we give guidance on Formation and you can see that below, copy pasted from our notes (I think it can be improved but that's as of 12/7/2023) and I don't think this is misrepresenting in any way what Formation is or tricking anyone into thinking it is something else. 2. Adults are adults, we are not responsible for anyone's LinkedIns just like Codesmith isn't responsible for them. The reason I did my post was because it was a pattern of 92% of recent Codesmith placements. 3. If someone said that 92% of Formation placements were listing Formation as a fake job and people were all not following our advice and going rogue by presenting Formation some kind of full time software engineer job experience, and that was the reason they were getting jobs…

Read full post →

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
I love the last paragraph you wrote and fully agree with that. Anyways, I'm sorry you feel attacked on this post, I don't agree with the tone of people calling you a liar or a paid ad and wish this was a much more useful discussion about how on earth you were the one of the only people out of hundreds right now to get a FAANG job post Codesmith because I'm sure you have a lot interesting things to say about your unique journey.

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
In all seriousness, the reason for Codesmith alumni's heavy, anonymous presence on Reddit is becasue people [exaggerate to get jobs](https://www.reddit.com/r/codingbootcamp/comments/18cpq98/analysis_of_52_most_recent_codesmith_offers/) and if they out themselves on LinkedIn or somewhere else or give more details about who they are, they risk getting "found out" by colleagues and losing those jobs. I talk to my friend at a recent hiring and asked them if they knew a specific Codesmith grad the company just hired a few weeks ago had no experience (obviously friendly and off the books) and they said no idea from the resume or interview. So it's totally in people's interest to not share their success in any way that might reveal who they are, if it's based on stretching the truth. At Formation, we had someone start at Meta this week and she happily participated in a blog post about her job…

Read full post →

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
This is on the high side but when all said and done with base, signing, base performance, and stock, this is in that range. But are Google and Meta hiring entry level engineers right now. I asked Meta recruiters and they only have a small number of return interns coming in at E3 right now. There are a number of REng (E4 rotational) starting this week but their pay in non negotiable and fixed (yes - truly non negotiable and it's not 230K, it's right about 200K because the signing bonus is split over 2 years.) The E4 rotational program requires 2 years of SWE experience and it's firm. We work with their recruiters for that program and they won't take people under 2 YOE so if a Codesmith person with no experience lied, I'll give them a heads up to dive deeper into that. If someone lied to get into that program (OP said they have no experience) they should NOT be posting on Reddit because…

Read full post →

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
I can assure you I have the raw data to back that there have not been 60 placements reported in the past month and I crossed checked my number with people who work there. If you make incorrect assumptions about my data sources then that's on you for spreading misinformation and people won't trust you on here.

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
This is a common problem with the Codesmith approach (not the majority, but it's a common thing to happen) and there's a number of people at career accelerators like Formation, Interview Kickstart, Pathrise, etc... as a result. The Codesmith approach can really throw off your mental model of the industry because you hustle into roles many people are not ready for or the right fit for, and have a hard time understanding what to do next. It works if you keep the hustle going until you land a solid legit tech job, but it doesn't handle the other cases so well. This market is making Codesmith grads learn quickly that you are not a mid level or senior engineer at top tier companies. So you get stuck with not getting these interviews, not knowing why, and then failing the mid-level/senior top tier interviews you do get. (This is the pattern I've seen). With the exaggerations seen in most r…

Read full post →

Analysis of 52 most recent Codesmith offers LinkedIns and trends on who is getting a job right now and why. Summary: an average of 11.7 months of experience claimed for 3 week long projects (lacking evidence of additional time spent). Majority claimed to have prior SWE-adjacent experience. · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
I don't know what "support" means but.I can list out what I've seen people do. Codemsith adamantly claims to not help people lie so I assume they'd re not helping with most of this but it's possible they are and that is "support" 1. Stretch things, turning fast food-like jobs into technical jobs 2. Go back to school 3. Work at Codemsith itself, either as an instructor or another role 4. Be a fellow and stretch the length of time on that 5. Do unpaid internships or contracts that aren't documented as placements I told they can neither convert or get another job 6. Work on projects independent of Codemsith 7. Do another paid program afterwards, like an interview prep or career accelerator 8. Follow Codemsith networking advice Codemsith will help any time with career support conversations so they offer those to all these people, but there isn't anything tangible that they do specifically f…

Read full post →

Analysis of 52 most recent Codesmith offers LinkedIns and trends on who is getting a job right now and why. Summary: an average of 11.7 months of experience claimed for 3 week long projects (lacking evidence of additional time spent). Majority claimed to have prior SWE-adjacent experience. · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Those people have a really hard time, but they often do eventually get jobs by some way that seems to be unique for each one, or they give up and end up in the 20% of I graduated or unplaced people. Like Codesmith is just 13 weeks and you can do a heck of a lot in the 6 months to 12 months afterwards that your job hunting to keep developing and growing, heck, you could start your own company! Codesmith does not really support these people though to be very blunt and I talk to a number of them or work with them. But those who don't give up eventually get jobs. It's definitely a let down for some because they expected a six-figure job and they are definitely some of the more unhappy people and maybe I'm biased because I talked to a number of these people but yeah don't know what else to say, very case by case. But it's one of the motivations for calling this out so often, many are misled…

Read full post →

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
This is one of the reasons why I so adamantly believe that people need to get appropriate first jobs out of a boot camp. what that means is different for each person but getting an entry level FAANG job that pays not as high as potentially some other jobs achieved through exaggerating resumes and pushing really hard, can be the path rapidly accelerating your career. If Codesmith was really the ivy league like grad school for bootcamps they claim to be. they should be striving to place people in incredible entry-level rules that result in them making $600,000 in a few years and instead they are dismissive of those roles and pushing people to these exaggerated mid-level senior looking roles and pushing people to make the highest compensation they possibly can right out of the program. I think they know that this is pretty much impossible because they can't reliably get people these jobs…

Read full post →

Analysis of 52 most recent Codesmith offers LinkedIns and trends on who is getting a job right now and why. Summary: an average of 11.7 months of experience claimed for 3 week long projects (lacking evidence of additional time spent). Majority claimed to have prior SWE-adjacent experience. · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Sadly Codemsith has a "sister company" charity called OSLabs that signs letters of reference and does reference check calls. I have evidence that they sign off on 4 months plus any additional time you claimed to have worked on the project (example letters of reference, and an employee confirming this publicly) A grad claimed 10 months on LinkedIn and said it was because "people have the option of continuing to work on their projects" yet the project was untouched after the initial development window of about a month. I do not have evidence if Codesmith would sign off on 10 months of experience but this person seems to think they did 10 months and if they told Codesmith this, would they sign off on it?

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Yeah absolutely even 2 people a cohort is like 5% of people and wouldn't surprise me at all that it's that or a bit higher, it's just not remotely representative of the entire experience and people framing this like its a typical case can be extremely misleading. No problem celebrating these placements with appropriate disclaimers.

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Can you provide there have been 60 offers in the past month because there are doubts of that claim. The CEO and outcomes advisor have been saying that but people who work there and my own independent analysis could not support that claim and we independent came up with a much smaller number, about one per day. Ask for proof of that number before believing them.

Analysis of 52 most recent Codesmith offers LinkedIns and trends on who is getting a job right now and why. Summary: an average of 11.7 months of experience claimed for 3 week long projects (lacking evidence of additional time spent). Majority claimed to have prior SWE-adjacent experience. · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Yeah I see to varying degrees as well in other programs and it's most pronounced in Codesmith but I see all kinds of things with non traditional engineers and am very open minded 1-1 to helping people find their path. The reason to call it out is because Codesmith is the only one claiming over and over that it produces "mid level and senior engineers" and signs letters of reference for their open source projects via their "sister charity" OSLabs to back up this open source work for background checks.

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
I think the last thing you said is the key, I wrote about that before and there are four buckets I've observed and almost all of them it is not the celebratory story, but a grueling first year of stress: \- get fired, not a lot, but some people do \- barely get by and leave before getting PIPed or because they are no where near progressing and want a more appropriate role \- secretly put in nights and weekends to make up for their gaps and get by long enough to hang on \- other: the jobs aren't really "senior", e.g. consultants at Google via contractors are "Senior Engineer", they are more mid level-ish and there is another set of outcomes there The key thing with Codesmith is the entry bar is very high and looking for a very specific person - a person who tends to be successful in a lot of situations.

Analysis of 52 most recent Codesmith offers LinkedIns and trends on who is getting a job right now and why. Summary: an average of 11.7 months of experience claimed for 3 week long projects (lacking evidence of additional time spent). Majority claimed to have prior SWE-adjacent experience. · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
I mean the community is amazing, the people are just really well spoken, great and interesting people. There are a lot of reasons to go there! If you are cruising Reddit late at night pondering a career switch and stumble upon Codesmith and see $120K placements and think "sign me up!", definitely slow down and learn about how it works and see if it's what you want first - same goes for any program!! And you'll find a lot of more legit reasons to go there, or not go there, depending on what you want.

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
https://youtu.be/SkWYanfkfCY?si=d7jFHlVV0grjKuPN&t=1980 "There's this one guy Eric Kirsten, who has a silver tongue and he will teach you how to say anything. You tell him this is my background, how do I present it to an employer to where it doesn't look like I just decided to switch careers \[\] and he will give you a great way to say it"

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
By lying :( The people I know from Codesmith basically had to have resumes that showed 4+ years of experience to qualify for "senior" at Capital One and they 'worked with Career Support Engineers' to help make that happen. There's a tight crew at Capital One and they even help each other out, like one person did a wink wink 'hey how many years of experience do you have' - candidate said 2 - person said - make it 4 to qualify for this role. And somehow they got the job. Maybe I'm being too negative, because it doesn't come out of thin air. People turn their past jobs into 'engineer-sounding' jobs. Illustrative examples like Auditor -> Technical Analyst. Teacher -> Technical Instructor. Customer Support -> Operations Engineer. They have a outcomes advisor that one grad said has a "silver tongue" and can make anything sound good who can help with these kinds of things.

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
lol I'm glad I can have some amicable discourse in here. Codesmith has a number of amazing placements out thousands of Alumni, there are a few dozen at Amazon, a dozen or two at Google, a smaller amount at Meta, a handful at Apple/Netflix. 100 (being very generous/rounding up) canonical FAANG placements out of THOUSANDS is an edge that people should not be using an as example nor should anyone be making decisions off of. But that doesn't change the fact that a number of incredible people go to Codesmith and do incredibly well in their careers and I both encourage them to go there, support them while they are there, support them after they are there, and that's how it should be, I'm not hear to tear anyone down or bash on their achievements.

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
So Codesmith has like 50/60 or so Capital One placements ranging from Associate to Senior Associate to Senior SWE. Senior SWEs make about 160 to 170K base + a base performance bonus (say 8%) + signing bonus (say 30K) + maybe the perosn is including 6% 401K matching. It could get to 230K for first year TC on the high end yeah, but I could see it getting there. Entry level FAANG is around 200K right now that I'm seeing and mid level is around 300K I'm seeing, so these "senior" alumni are kind of hitting "mid level"-equivalent Capital One roles.

Analysis of 52 most recent Codesmith offers LinkedIns and trends on who is getting a job right now and why. Summary: an average of 11.7 months of experience claimed for 3 week long projects (lacking evidence of additional time spent). Majority claimed to have prior SWE-adjacent experience. · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati posted · ★ FEATURED
Analysis of 52 most recent Codesmith offers LinkedIns and trends on who is getting a job right now and why. Summary: an average of 11.7 months of experience claimed for 3 week long projects (lacking evidence of additional time spent). Majority claimed to have prior SWE-adjacent experience. Hi all, I was recently made aware of the 52 most recent reported Codesmith placements (not saying when this was provided to protect identities, but it's from a window within the past couple months) and did a summary of how those people present themselves on LinkedIn. Please note that this is an UNOFFICIAL ANALYSIS based on an ordered list of placements during a 2 month time window. I won't be DOXing anyone on the list, and because this is just my personal analysis and not an official study, you should use this information for illustrative purposes only. There are numerous ways you can try to reproduce…

Read full post →

From Codesmith to FAANG · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
I'll run in through several sources and see if it checks out. In my sources personally, I haven't seen FAANG placements from Codesmith for a while, so I'm curious what "recently" means, and what "FAANG" means. Someone got a job paying 400K at Netflix, that wasn't a SWE role and was in the same field that the person had 8 years of background as a high performer in. There were one or two Capital One placements that could be 230K TC, but that's not a FAANG company.

We tested Le Wagon's job placement data (using graduate profiles on LinkedIn) · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Yeah I did analysis of how people present themselves on LinkedIn. Codesmith's placement numbers themselves in their CIRR are accurate. The numbers their senior advisor throws around are less so more like mischaracterizing. My data shows that the average recent Codesmith placement (reported job in past few months) claimed to have 11.7 months of experience on their LinkedIn from their 3 week group project. So while the outcomes themselves are good, people might be exaggerating or mischaracterizing their backgrounds to get there.

Has anyone had a good experience at a bootcamp this year? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Yeah for sure, here's a job post from BloomTech (aka Lamba School): [https://jobs.lever.co/BloomTech/bc039ed3-2ba8-4e4f-a434-616f75ef667d](https://jobs.lever.co/BloomTech/bc039ed3-2ba8-4e4f-a434-616f75ef667d) "You will be responsible for managing and executing various marketing campaigns across multiple channels to drive engagement, brand awareness, and customer acquisition" "Implement and maintain marketing operations tools, platforms, and processes to streamline workflows, improve efficiency, and enhance campaign execution." "Develop and execute multi-channel marketing campaigns across email, CRM, Facebook, and TikTok to achieve marketing goals and objectives." \------ VS Codesmith: "Foster positive relationships with Codesmith enthusiasts and leverage advocates to amplify the brand message." "Proactively participate in discussions to influence the narrative around Codesmith…

Read full post →

Has anyone had a good experience at a bootcamp this year? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
This doesn't inspire me to share, bootcamps manipulating discussion in this subreddit. Job posting: [https://codesmith.applytojob.com/apply/8cJdwgcb9g/Brand-Architect-And-Content-Lead](https://codesmith.applytojob.com/apply/8cJdwgcb9g/Brand-Architect-And-Content-Lead) >\- Foster positive relationships with Codesmith enthusiasts and leverage advocates to amplify the brand message. \- Proactively participate in discussions to influence the narrative around Codesmith. \- Strong understanding of online community dynamics, with experience managing brand perception on platforms.

Has anyone had a good experience at a bootcamp this year? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Like this: Codesmith is also hiring someone to manipulate Reddit full time: [https://codesmith.applytojob.com/apply/8cJdwgcb9g/Brand-Architect-And-Content-Lead](https://codesmith.applytojob.com/apply/8cJdwgcb9g/Brand-Architect-And-Content-Lead) > \- Foster positive relationships with Codesmith enthusiasts and leverage advocates to amplify the brand message. \- Proactively participate in discussions to influence the narrative around Codesmith. \- Strong understanding of online community dynamics, with experience managing brand perception on platforms. I'm sure as more grads are used to "amplify the brand message" and "influence the narrative". An alternate proposal: I would stop being so suspicious of success posts about people with "no experience" making $130K, if they stopped looking the other way when 48 out of your 52 recent placements list their 3 week long OSP as an aver…

Read full post →

Has anyone had a good experience at a bootcamp this year? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
There is a lot of negatively directed towards the job market and not the bootcamps themselves IMO. Chris from Launch School said it well, their outcomes in later 2023 will likely be lower than in the past, but the education is the same, the experience is the same, and the graduates have the same technical bar, it's the market that's changed. The programs complained about the most were often complained about even in the good market. I did an analysis of the 52 most recent Codesmith placements (which I might publish soon) and people are getting jobs! But that average person claimed their 3 week group project was 11.7 months of "experience" on their LinkedIn and the majority (about 2/3) claimed to have some kind of relevant past experience (systems engineer, developer, tech project manager, data analyst, etc...) so I'm sure people are still having great experiences, but clearly the bar t…

Read full post →

Have you had a bad experience at a bootcamp in 2023? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
It's Formation ([formation.dev](https://formation.dev)). It's for people with 1 year or more SWE work experience (and typically MUCH more) but a lot of people we work with are doing their 2nd, 3rd, 4th job transition. We're not a school or education program or teach anything, rather it's practice and mentorship experience to get interview ready at top tier companies.

2023 for a Jr-Md level dev looking to advance career: Bootcamp? Masters? Advice · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Here's a great job post from Codesmith, they are looking for someone to manipulate social media on their behalf -Foster positive relationships with Codesmith enthusiasts and leverage advocates to amplify the brand message. -Proactively participate in discussions to influence the narrative around Codesmith. Its also news to me that they have 5000 immersive alumni and hundreds of people in FAANG jobs.... I count a lot less. https://codesmith.applytojob.com/apply/8cJdwgcb9g/Brand-Architect-And-Content-Lead

If you just HAD to choose a coding bootcamp now which one would you choose? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Don't DOX anyone, but can give general cases: 1. We haven't offered ISAs for like 7 months now so it's going to be a smaller and smaller number of people in that bucket. But someone on an ISA who lost their job, their ISA stop the second they lost their job. If they don't get a job within another 12 months then it's nullified, if they do, it continues where they left off when they were laid off. 2. If they were not on ISA, then they paid upfront. They could return to Formation, likely with a discount, case by case and depending on the circumstances. But many people would choose to leverage the alumni community the best they can and not pay to return because their skills are still fresh enough. Layoffs are very personal and happen for all kinds of reasons and don't happen that often, so each one is case by case, but that's a generalization.

Is it worth going to Codesmith? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
This person has been copy pasting this review on allo f the negative Codesmith posts from the past year. It's suspicious behavior. Codesmith's leadership were saying earlier this week in a public info session call that they had 60 placements in the past month and it doesn't check out with the raw data some people inside Codesmith sent me who were upset that the leaders said this. I put a pause since then on my recommendation of going there until I can sort it out (and it's not something I'm urgently working on because I'm busy with real things to do) People are definitely getting placed still but there are some unknowns. I also have a list of all the recent placements to go through in detail because I spot checked some with a long time industry person who doesn't know what Codesmith was and the person though their LinkedIns were all complete lies (e.g. 8 months of Software Engineer e…

Read full post →

2023 for a Jr-Md level dev looking to advance career: Bootcamp? Masters? Advice · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
And other people are concerned about Codesmith 'finding them and suing them' (almost a direct quote from someone but changed to protect the person) and don't even post at all. For example the recent negative post about Codesmith was deleted, and another recent one deleted their account entirely, two other people contacted me who feel like they were "paid off" (both direct quotes in their words, not mine) after complaining about various things at Codesmith (one internally, one on Reddit who they found). Clearly this is not healthy in both directions but clearly there are reasons why it is this way that haven't been untangled yet and no other bootcamp has this kind of pattern of extreme polarization. Like I said, I have a day job (which has nothing to do with this situation, but I accept whatever people send me so keep it coming and I'll keep reporting what checks out and that I can ano…

Read full post →

If you just HAD to choose a coding bootcamp now which one would you choose? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Yeah I do often disclose and hear you on that. I comment all the time in this sub and people tend to know me but that's on me to keep explaining. The membership is not lifetime, it's unlimited access to Formation until you get a job. Many people pay again again for their next job hunt. If you have 4 years or more of SWE experience that is the average increased first year total compensation reported. The methodology is explained in great detail but this is a new calculator that people asked for to understand the long term value of Formation. Our outcomes are indeed very very strong but I think the weakness is maybe the time it takes because it takes about 6 months of part time mentorship to get there and its no small commitment, you have to be ready and all In.

Do Not Go To Codesmith · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
It really depends on you and your timeframe. If you have a longer timeframe, I would consider first self teaching, then doing a more intense self-paced online program/course, and then doing open source contributions or starting a company/building a product from scratch. You can put that 20K into hiring some freelancers and registering an LLC and building something for real. There is simply no program that will get you there. There's a saying going around that if you can get accepted by Codesmith on the first interview, run for the hills and save your $20K because that means you are pretty much ready to go and just need a little connecting of the dots to get there. Happy to chat more if you want to share more personal background for more specific advice, it's hard to generalize.

2023 for a Jr-Md level dev looking to advance career: Bootcamp? Masters? Advice · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
If you think that is useful then you should definitely check out the above more. The career support engineers at Codemsith are typically Fellows/peers you would have at Formation (at least one I know of has been a Fellow actually) and the mentors are more knowledgeable. For example someone got a Senior E5 Meta offer this week and chatted the next day with a recruiter with 30 years of FAANG level recruiter experience. But depending on your situation that might not be the support you are looking for and need. I highly encourage anyone to make use of the Codesmith scholarship and get free dedicated help, that's awesome!

2023 for a Jr-Md level dev looking to advance career: Bootcamp? Masters? Advice · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
I'm extremely bias because I'm the co-founder of one of these, but based on everything you should look into career accelerator/interview prep programs and see if you think they would be worth it for helping out. I'm fairly confident this type of thing would help, but they are all expensive and it's a personal decision if you think they are worth the cost for you. Formation.dev, Pathrise, Interview Kickstart are the three biggest ones left standing right now. They are generally a bit cheaper than bootcamps but roughly the same price but solely focused on all the areas: brushing up on CS concepts, strategizing for the interviews, legit mock interviews, building robust problem solving skills, system design etc... I can go into more about all these if interested, but first just check them out and see if they would help you or not.

Is a bootcamp right for me if I’m already pretty good at programming but have no actual experience? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
If you are answering the check in emails and saying you didn't get a job then they won't count it. If you entirely ghost then they will try to find you and have any friends you had on staff text you to see how life is going and try to get info. CIRR has two fields to try to counter this: 1. Salary unavailable (so if they count it as a placement because of LI and you ghosted them it would show up in this field) 2. Job placed out of field. The definition is if the skills you learned are needed on the job or not. Codesmith teaches 5 things and only 1 is programming skills, the rest are soft skills, so not sure how they interpret that rule.

Is a bootcamp right for me if I’m already pretty good at programming but have no actual experience? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Want to know something crazy but Codemsith often rejects people on their first try even if they are qualified so they can prove how much they want to go to Codesmith. If you really want to go, you'll fight to get in. So that said, yeah if you get in your first try, you have no hope in a bootcamp and run for the hills.

Is a bootcamp right for me if I’m already pretty good at programming but have no actual experience? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Also a +1000 for how often I get similar messages privately to your analysis.... They have marketing efforts to brand it as the solution for anyone great to get a 130K salary but it's really no where near that level of program, it as a bootcamp, it's fantastic. I wish Codesmith would realize this. Several staff members call their leaders delusional and have left or are leaving shortly but haven't told them yet. Instead of being so delusional that you are creating mid level and senior engineers in 13 weeks, be honest with yourself and be honest with residents, everyone will be better off... go back to why you are doing this to begin with..m i.e. this https://vimeo.com/42713491

Is a bootcamp right for me if I’m already pretty good at programming but have no actual experience? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Hi! Can you comment on your perception of Codesmith before and after joining? If you could share some things you perceived before starting that were as expected and not as expected that would be super helpful based on the questions people ask me daily. I'm very much on top of Codemsith on here because it attracts both the right people and the wrong people and I want to make sure everyone ends up at the right place for them and gets past marketing.

Please do not join any coding bootcamp · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
I'm way more middle road than I come across here. People can do whatever they want, and some people are in circumstances where they stretch the truth for personal reasons consciously. But people who come here are are like "$150K, Codesmith, mic drop" is just very car-saleperson-y that makes people want to go there for the wrong reasons. If you are super ambitious - as many Codesmith students are there might be a number of pathways that could work better than Codesmith and judging the $$$ alone isn't ideal and in their outcomes advisor throws around big offer numbers like candy - "I was talking on the phone to someone this morning and she had a 150 and we got a 10 signing bonus" - not the lack of use of the "K" or "thousands"

Codesmith cohort - one year later · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Yeah I agree Codesmith is still one of the best bootcamps, they just bill themselves as an elite grad school and are unabashedly talking about how good they are in all the talks I see and I see graduates carry forward that vibe... when on paper they are doing like a "good bootcamp" education and not anywhere close to something billing itself as an way better. For gosh sakes, their contract is a Google Form equivalent that doesn't meet basic requirements of a contract, it's a one way form. If you have paperwork showing what your IP relationship is with OS Labs then I would back off on that. I hadn't seen it in the contracts sent to me by people asking about things in them.

Codesmith cohort - one year later · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Correct, Formation is not ideal for bootcamp grads who can't get jobs right now. We have people who joined the hot market with no experience and we stand by our unconditional support until they get a job but it's a rough market and we don't do miracles . We take a very very small number of people who do it with no experience while job hunting because they don't care about the cost and want structure instead of just job hunting alone but they enter with reasonable expectations. So you can consider it but I would strongly recommend getting a job first and coming back in the future when you are ready to level up.

Codesmith cohort - one year later · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Yeah but do you sign any paperwork that you are part of OSLabs or that you are admitted to it? I volunteered for a number of charities and you always have to sign paperwork. Otherwise your IP contributions are ambiguous. If you aren't just committing open source code but are a part of OSLabs, then your contributions to the projects they own (regardless of open source or not, they own them) need clear IP ownership. If they aren't educating you on how open source really works, then you arent being prepared to use open source properly on the job either. I learned all this almost immediately st Facebook and many friends learn about it too at their companies. If you are going to be a mid-level or senior engineer and you aren't learning this stuff, that is a major hole. Codemsith can't have it bofh ways. If they want to use open source to accelerate people then do right... otherwise it's a…

Read full post →

Codesmith cohort - one year later · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
This is why I so strongly eco this loud and clear no matter who pushes back or no matter how much Codesmith leadership badmouths me to their staff to try to turn them against me.... you know what their response to my recent wave of calling this out: 'Codesmith is the best and the best always attracts haters'. No... systematically supporting lying and looking the other way attracts haters.

Codesmith cohort - one year later · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
Thanks, I largely agree with your assessment too and it's why I try so hard to help the right people go there. People who go just because of the outcomes won't do well.without those other traits and attitude. RE: OSP, it's a straight up lie that you worked for 3 months on the OSP and Phil saying that is actual fraud if he said that he does that. I understand that he thinks all of the time at Codesmith goes into that OSP but residents are also listing all of their other projects on their resume too, and their tech talks, and their "publications" (I e. medium post about the OSP) and that is all double or triple counted if you are getting 3 months credit for the OSP. That said, they will also verify time spent after Codesmith. I found someone who removed a word from the README file 4 months later and they claimed 7 or 8 months in their LinkedIn. I know several alumni who are floating 1 t…

Read full post →

Please do not join any coding bootcamp · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
This post is sadly something I hear often right now and is why I'm not happy about CIRR changing their metric from 6 months placements to 12 months placements. So much happens in that year of job hunting that it's largely irrelevant what the bootcamp did. The bootcamp could do nothing and then you could spend NINE MONTHS studying DS&A and get a job and the bootcamp gets credit. Anyways, sorry to hear about this. I know it's doom and gloom but it's also true that the market is just overloaded for entry level and the only consistent path I'm seeing is if you are a new grad from a top school, all other placements are one off. Sorry and Codesmith grads that lie about their experience are also getting placed.

Codesmith cohort - one year later · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
I also monitor Codesmith offers and one interesting thing going on here, is there are a number of people being placed who have been job hunting for almost a year now. They still list their OSP as X - present, so the longer it takes them to get a job, the more fake work experience it looks like they have. This is the dirty secret in many of the struggling-graduate Codesmith resumes I see (many people send me resumes for reviews outside of my day job). As /u/SlowestTriathlete said, they are trying to motivate graduates by showing recovering results. The market is indeed doing better, but it's not doing better for people without any experience. Congrats on doing well btw! It gets lost in my post but one thing Codesmith does very well is choose amazing peope to let in who really give it their all.

Does codesmith seriously get people "senior" level SWE roles with no prior experience? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Yeah their lead instructor tells people no one looks at the projects. I did and posted on Reddit about some many security issues like secrets checked in, sql injection, and no auth on a delete endpoint, and the response internally was people assuring themselves their code is at the mid level bar and that I was being an asshole.

Does codesmith seriously get people "senior" level SWE roles with no prior experience? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · ★ FEATURED
Just by lying. For example Software Engineer, Kronos 2022- present People who do this don't even say they are lying! They say it's true just missing the months they were there and the last line of a 6 bullet point write up says, "product accelerated by OSLabs" and they think that is transparent disclosure that it was not paid..... but at the same time have this under experience placed right beside another section called "Open Source" with their personal projects which clearly makes that look like experience..m if it was open source why would it not be in the Open Source section?

Does codesmith seriously get people "senior" level SWE roles with no prior experience? · r/codingbootcamp

u/michaelnovati replied · · edited ★ FEATURED
So if the startup doesn't have scale and doesn't have process, a person can get by easier through sheer will compared to a FAANG. At FAANG, performance is calibrated and our performers are aggressively PIPed and fired. At a startup, lots of hustle might carry you, even if you are clearly operating at a lower level but adding value. I actually hired a Codesmith grad as an entry level engineer (I think Codesmith called it mid-level in their stats, which was very clearly entry level but compensated against top tier benchmark) and this is the level all the Codesmith grads I work with are at immediately after Codesmith... should be going for entry level top tier jobs. Many people tell me about how their outcomes advisor pushed people away from that roles and says they are grunteork roles that set your career back... but that's extremely inconsistent with what I've seen.... people who take m…

Read full post →