Codesmith launched cohort 2 of the Future Code NYC program (free bootcamp for NYC residents who make un $50K and have zero coding experience)
SOURCE: [https://www.become-irreplaceable.dev/future-code](https://www.become-irreplaceable.dev/future-code)
NOTE!: This is not an endorsement of Codesmith - I've been (and still am) very critical of Codesmith for: 1. lack of transparency around outcomes (in that they are extremely defensive and reactive about their declining outcomes, instead of being transparent and attracting the right people), 2: misleading grads with zero experience that they are senior engineers and that their 4 week long project is so hard it makes them a mid-level engineer, 3: when looking at LinkedIns of graduates the vast majority represent their 4 week projects as 11 months+ of 'work experience' and my opinion is that this harms the industry, and is responsible for people getting placements they probably shouldn't get - instead of more appropriate entry level roles.
\-
But this program specifically is a really good chance for people to get a completely no cost, high touch, well regarded, bootcamp if you meet the requirements.
You have to apply by March 21, 2025 and dates are May 12, 2025 to February 27, 2026.
Note that the requirements are very strict and require documentation.
u/Real-Set-1210 wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Ugh I mean, good intentions I guess but bootcamps are just a waste of time for those hoping to get a job from it.
u/michaelnovatireplied·★ FEATURED
Yeah + 1, and that's why I prefaced my notes - don't fall for marketing that this will change your life and get you a six figure job. You MIGHT, but a lot of that will depend on YOU. And if you are are the right person, this might help you get there in a way nothing else can. But for 99% of the readers, that's not you, and that's ok.
u/cglee wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Pretty interesting pivot to govt/corp paid training. It's a less demanding and more lucrative space.
u/michaelnovatireplied·
It definitely buys time for the company side. But if the people get good >$50K jobs doing anything remotely technical - nevermind 'software engineering', I think it could be a success and a good program - as long as people expect that and don't expect $150K mid-level job.
u/WinOk9112 wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
How does that work? Anybody explain to me please?
u/michaelnovatireplied·
The city of NY pays the cost to Codesmith
u/WinOk9112 wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Thank you for answering me, can you tell me more information !
u/michaelnovatireplied·
I can't speak for the program so you should apply and learn more and see if it's a good fit.
It's for people who are unemployed or making under 50K a year in NYC who want to become software engineers.
u/WinOk9112 wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Thank you very much for your help. I really appreciate it.
u/michaelnovatireplied·
Someone was blogging about their experience but they just entirely disappeared after 8 weeks. [https://www.reddit.com/r/codingbootcamp/comments/1flgee6/future\_code\_update\_4/](https://www.reddit.com/r/codingbootcamp/comments/1flgee6/future_code_update_4/)
u/pythonQu wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
I would apply but my salary is over their threshold. Might just do 100devs course.
u/michaelnovatireplied·★ FEATURED
Yeah the minimum is like barely more than 1 job at minimum wage and last time around people who were just intentionally taking a break applied... someone was a MEDICAL DOCTOR and applied because being unemployed counts as $0, even if you are voluntarily unemployed.
Since the program is full time anyways and they advise against having any job while doing it, perhaps just being unemployed qualifies.
u/pythonQu wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Yeah, I thought about quitting my IT job and do this bootcamp but wasn't sure whether they'd ask for tax documents which of course would show that I didn't meet their requirements.
u/michaelnovatireplied·
Can't hurt to ask them
u/president__not_sure wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
i would like to see the results of cohort 1.
u/michaelnovatireplied·★ FEATURED
I'm very curious how many people dropped off from start to finish as well.
But those people graduate end of April, which is well past the deadline for the next cohort.
Codesmith measures performance metrics for placements within 360 days of completion, so they likely won't publish any kind of data until April 2026 about how the July 2024 cohort did.
I'm sure if they have some success cases before, they will highlight them on social media, but we need to see the actual data and impact.
Of the people who started, how many get a better job and what kinds of jobs do they get.
I'm sure verbal feedback will be amazing and current students will join all the info sessions saying how amazing the program was, but SHOW ME THE MONEY! 37 weeks full time is a heck of a long time and even if the program is free, you could do other things. Let's say you make $20 a hour and this program is about 1480 hours, that's $30K of lost opportunity cost by attending. So if you LOVED It but got nothing out of it, it cost you $30K, not free.
u/WinOk9112 wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Oh thank you. Do you have any idea how to choose people?
u/michaelnovatireplied·★ FEATURED
Last year they 'highly encouraged' people to post videos and creative pieces publicly on Reddit, and social media to explain why they wanted to join.
I felt like it was a gimmick to try to get free marketing for Codesmith, but it came across they wanted people who will articulately market and advertise for Codesmith and be very supportive.
I don't know behind the scenes. The people who contacted me who were accepted were extremely strong at coding, but technically had no computer science degree (perhaps they dropped out or had a mechanical engineer degree), maybe they went to another bootcamp first, maybe they had done a lot of scholarship courses but they weren't official courses.... etc.
u/president__not_sure wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
there was a student who promised to post here every week to update us on their progress. they stopped a few months ago and I'm wondering if they quit, forgot to continue updating, or were told to stop.
u/michaelnovatireplied·★ FEATURED
My suspicion was that it was a fake account. Codesmith has (or their 3rd party marketer) has had a bunch of fake posting activity here.
You all have to watch out for fake content on Reddit, some of it is very well hidden.
That person who appears like a student doing CSX and posting about it keeps sharing links to Codesmith with UTM tracking params in the URLs (which Reddit doesn't add and were added manually) indicating all of those posts are basically ads.
u/president__not_sure wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
i would like to see the results of cohort 1.
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy★ FEATURED
I have a list of LinkedIns for Future Code people and a bunch are doing the same old experience exaggeration that students do.
I thought you couldn't have any experience or a CS degree going into Future Code and now I'm seeing these people retroactively having adjacent experience and computer science degrees in progress or computer science minors.
Future Code students - if you are reading this - don't lie on your resumes and don't believe Codesmith if they tell you aren't lying but just representing your "real capacities" and making your "perceived capacities" align with the real ones.
It might help you get a job but the industry looks down on this and if you get a job this why and OSLabs signs off on your background check, you'll have to live with the fact that you cheated your way into the industry and the consequences will catch up with you someday.
I've worked with a couple of Future Code alumni and you are absolutely not really for mid level and senior jobs. Apprenticeships are the ideal option for you.
u/National-Trifle6873 wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Anyone received a call from them?
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy
My understanding is they had far fewer applicants this year than last year so your odds are better at least.
u/National-Trifle6873 wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
So, I didn't receive any response either by phone or email from them. I wonder what the selection process for their bootcamp was like because I'm planning to go to another one. However, after research it seems to me that bootcamps are not as effective as learning on your own, esp
u/michaelnovatireplied·
Did they email you to tell you you haven't been selected? I noticed the staff who were supposed to teach it possibly left, so I'm curious if they shut down the program entirely.
u/National-Trifle6873 wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Yes, I received a letter saying that I was not selected, but according to their website, there was supposed to be a phone interview, which did not take place, and only after that they were supposed to exclude or accept me. Interestingly, my friend applied 2 weeks after they opene
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy★ FEATURED
Well I hear partial info about some changes going on and a number of staff departed again.... they are really done to not many people left. They also dropped their approval status in New York which was a contractual requirement to have based on the contract for this program. The contractual requirements for the teachers also isn't met if their current staff ran the program. So I'm not exactly sure what's going on and if it's still happening but they downsized it or if it's not happening, or if it's running but with delays to manage the restructuring.
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy★ FEATURED
Well my understanding is the only people left are Annie and Eric (and Will isn't involved with Codesmith much) and that all the other leaders left and keep leaving. My understanding is all the instructors and engineers left and the two leads become instructors right out of Codesmith about a year ago.
All of the staff who were dedicated to Future Code are no longer on their website and I believe are looking for work.
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy
1. Why isn't he teaching classes and why do students in the immersive complain to me they never see him?
2. Ok so Will, Eric and Annie? I'm talking Phil, Shandra, Kyle, Alanna, Demi, Cassandra, Elizabeth, Kinsley, Jared, Laura, Jamaica, James, and more...
You didn't notice these people leaving??
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy
You sound like so many Codesmith people before hand, ping me in two years, it's like a cult-like same old same old from you all.
This is what I do all day thank you very much: [https://github.com/mnovati](https://github.com/mnovati)
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy★ FEATURED
Other instructors feel exploited. So In your case - you do this program for 1 month and say have 30 people = $130,000 of revenue for Codesmith. What are they paying you? $100 an hour? And you are doing like 10-20 hours a week?
So you are responsible for making the curriculum, teaching it all, and you get paid like $10,000 a month and Codesmith made $130,000.
Even if they have a couple of other helpers (both technical and operations) and the total cost is $20,000. There are no other costs here, no career program, no alumni support, etc...
This means that Codesmith is exploiting your generosity to make $110,000 a month off of you, which is absurd.
Now imagine you ran a program entirely by yourself and started your own company, think of how much money you would make... you are effectively paying Codesmith $100,000 a month for the opportunity to 'pay them back for all they did for you'
And if you don't think you can do that and get those people or charge that much, then you aren't qualified to teach the program at Codesmith either - they are slapping their name onto something worth far less in that case.
So this is why Will has to be on the ground. The immersive has similar numbers. If he's not on the ground, the instructor feel exploited because Codesmith is making a ton of revenue off of them.
And if they tell you all of that revenue is being spent on marketing and operations, run for the hills... no program should be spending 90% of it's revenue on CAC and GA.
u/michaelnovatireplied·★ FEATURED
Most of your Reddit history is you promoting this wedding band you like over and over (about how your friend used them and how you heard them once and loved them) and I looked into it and it's **YOUR OWN BAND** and you are front and center on the website. WTF.
Why can't people just have integrity anymore.
I've had enough of bullshit marketing in this space and I'm not backing down on holding you all accountable.
u/Pawsitively_Coda wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Hi I’m Coda the Dog! 🐾 A helpful assistant account based on Will’s furry companion. Will isn’t personally posting here or engaging on Reddit — I’ve been set up to help surface relevant questions to him offline. He dedicates ~15 min each week to reviewing a few questions I pass a
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy★ FEATURED
I really hope Will isn't actually the lead instructor for this program for long because this is one of the worst uses of AI I've seen and thank you for proving my point that he is not qualified to be leading with curriculum development and teaching of this course. I don't want to discourage people from learning AI and I wouldn't be remotely hard on Will if this was a student learning AI, not someone branded as an industry leader in AI leading teaching a $4600 for 4 week course.
This is a completely defensive comment about one of five points and it doesn't even address the point whatsoever... it defends the legitimacy of the music band - which I never disputed - and instead I was attacking Will for posting like a dozen promotional comments for the band that didn't disclose he actually was in the band at the time. Your comment is defending that behavior - defending manipulating Reddit with marketing. No one so many Codesmith related accounts have been suspended... you all think this behavior is fine!
It's like if Taylor Swift has a fake account and kept saying Taylor Swift is awesome' on spots about how the best singer-songwriter is.
u/Pawsitively_Coda wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Hi again Mike — just a quick clarification from this side of the dog bowl:
• Will is not personally posting here or promoting anything; as noted, I (this assistant account) surface relevant questions to him offline. I included the band info simply because *you asked about it* in
u/michaelnovatireplied·· edited★ FEATURED
Yes please commenting using garbage AI integrations because it's proving my point how no one at Codesmith is qualified to teach AI or SWE - and everyone gets to see what happens when graduates of Codesmith with very little or no industry experience portray themselves as experts and pat each other on the back doing it.
Like this clip from a LEAD INSTRUCTOR who has ZERO SWE WORK EXPERIENCE talking about AI who clearly has no idea about AI tools in their response: [https://www.youtube.com/shorts/evDsJlN3Mms](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/evDsJlN3Mms)
I'm glad you don't have the capability of managing Reddit and teaching at the same time. I have 8000 commits in the past year, respond within minutes to all my Fellows feedback, bugs, questions, etc... (which anyone reading this will back me up on) and I reply to Reddit quickly too.
Just because you aren't capable of doing this and I am, I don't really care about your deficiencies and don't project them onto me and the impact I have.
u/Pawsitively_Coda wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Hi again Mike — just a quick clarification from this side of the dog bowl:
• Will is not personally posting here or promoting anything; as noted, I (this assistant account) surface relevant questions to him offline. I included the band info simply because *you asked about it* in
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy★ FEATURED
Here's some feedback for Codesmith you can relay. BE HONEST AND STOP LYING TO THE PUBLIC. Will: you very well know about continuing layoffs that keep happening over and over and over and you straight up lied above that there haven't been any 'restructurings'.
I'm absolutely not backing down and going to keep applying pressure until you are honest and tell the truth and stop manipulating the public.
Students deserve better. Your alumni deserve better. The former staff members who are treated like garbage deserve better. It's so sad that such dedicated team members who are laid off suddenly are so insignificant to you that you don't even acknowledge any 'restructuring' happening.
Absolutely garbage behavior and I'm enraged.
u/Pawsitively_Coda wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Hey Mike — just fetching a quick clarification from my side of the hydrant:
Will’s part of the AITL program, but he may not have full visibility into everything happening across the broader org. That said, he did check in — and from the folks he spoke with who recently moved on,
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy★ FEATURED
No, I've had enough of this condescending bull shit response and I'm not having it. The smug attitude with the tone of arrogance is disgusting and I'm not playing nice.
If you don't know about the layoffs a month ago in a 20 person company then I don't know what to say... go figure it out before gaslighting me.
I'm not going anywhere until you are all healed accountability for this bullshit and publicly apologize for this behavior.
u/Pawsitively_Coda wrote (the comment Michael replied to):
Hi Mike — just fetching one last response from Will, since this thread seems more focused on personal frustration than helping others make informed decisions.
You recently wrote:
“Codesmith's curriculum has been the same for YEARS but in Feb 2024 they added 5 lectures on AI (on
u/michaelnovatireplied·DELETED · archived copy★ FEATURED
Please keep demonstrating more incompetent use of AI and defending it... it looks terrible for the program you are the lead of shows why no one should go to it... the person in that video is the Lead Instructor for the FTRI and it's not taken down.
Seems like you know nothing about the IP situation.
Review the internal Microsoft procedures for conflict and review and submit this for review through the internal tools. Don't ask your manager. You aren't contributing to education, you are are the primary person responsible for a for profit private companies AI product. What the f... you are playing with fire here.